Old Nui never once showed up for a light-celebration.

In this town, whenever a new light flickers on along the far shore, everyone throws a party. It’s a sign that someone has settled on the opposite bank. The town elder gives it a name, and the women hand out rice cakes — which, admittedly, usually go stale by the next day. Still, that was half the fun.

But Nui never came.

“Hey, Nui, this one’s a good one. A steady light, way up north.”

Old Toki called over the fence. Toki loved a good celebration, and she was always first in line to knead the rice cakes whenever a new light appeared.

“Not yet,” Nui said, and went back to scribbling in her notebook.

“Not yet? Until when?”

“Until it’s gone around three times.”

The shore of this town sits on the rim of a great wheel, slowly turning. So a distant light, watched long enough, eventually sinks below the edge — only to swing back around later. A full turn, it seems, takes quite a while.

Nui’s notebook was filled, page after page, with the names of lights that had vanished. Every one of them had been named by the town, celebrated by the town, and gone dark by the next turn. That notebook, by the way, had already had its cover replaced three times.

“Most new lights,” Nui liked to say, “are just flukes. Ice out there catching the sun. Give it one turn and it’s already dark.”

Toki made a sour face.

“If you go around saying that, we’d never get to celebrate anything.”

“Better than cheering for a fluke and getting laughed at later.”

Truth be told, Nui herself used to be the first to knead the rice cakes. As a young woman, she’d spotted a light in the eastern sky, run through town shouting that someone had arrived, and the whole place had celebrated. But by the next turn, the light was simply gone. Just a trick of the ice. After that, Nui stopped lighting the lamp on her porch. The oil was still there. She just never lit it.

Now, on this particular turn, a handful of new lights had appeared again. The town wasted no time naming and celebrating them. Nui stayed home and wrote it all down, using the grooves of her window frame as a ruler, measuring each light’s position by the width of a finger.

By the town’s rule, any light that stayed in exactly the same spot for three full turns was declared a real neighbor. A light that wandered, on the other hand, was dismissed as “restless” and left out of the festivities. Nobody could say anymore who had come up with that rule, or when.

But then.

When the third turn came around, every single light the town had celebrated had gone dark. Not one was left. Toki stood by the fence, looking deflated.

“Another dud.”

“Toki.” Nui looked up from her notebook. “Remember that light we left out? The one that couldn’t sit still.”

“Oh — the twitchy one. That’s not the real deal, though, right?”

“Take a look.”

Nui opened the notebook and showed her. Every celebrated light had sat frozen in the exact same spot, right up until it winked out. But the one they’d excluded — that one had drifted, turn after turn, the width of a single finger, always in the same direction.

“A light that never moves,” Nui said, “is just distant ice, sitting still. That’s why it looks stuck in one place.” Her finger traced the drifting path across the page. “A light that moves, though — that one’s crossing over. Only something actually getting closer would shift a little more with every turn.”

Toki’s mouth opened, and nothing came out.

“Steady means real, they say.” Nui gave a low laugh. “It was backward. The whole time.”

That night, Nui took the lamp down from her porch, checked the oil, and lit it. It was the first flame that lamp had held in decades. She hung it facing the twitchy, nameless light — as if to say, I’m over here.

Toki stood frozen for a while. Then she went inside, came back with her own lamp, and hung it beside Nui’s without a word.

As the town went dark and the festival lanterns were packed away one by one, at the edge of that shore, two old lamps burned on — leaning toward a light that still had no name.